Florida Requires a Replacement Cost Appraisal at Least Every Three Years. Is Your Association's Current?
The building limit on your policy rests on one number. When was it last checked?
Current as of November 9, 2026.
Renewal packets land in board inboxes between November and January, and most of the conversation is spent on the premium. The number that deserves the attention sits further up the declarations page. It is the building limit, and everything else on the policy is priced and paid against it.
Where that number came from, and when, is the question this article is about.
What section 718.111(11) requires
Under section 718.111(11)(a), Florida Statutes, every condominium association is required to carry adequate property insurance, regardless of what the declaration says. Adequacy is measured against replacement cost, and the statute is specific about the source. The figure must be determined by an independent insurance appraisal, or an update of a prior appraisal, at least once every three years.
Three years is the outer limit. The statute does not say that an appraisal which is thirty-five months old is current for pricing purposes. It says the association may not go longer than that without one.
Homeowners' associations under Chapter 720 are treated differently. No matching appraisal clause exists there, so for an HOA the obligation is set by the governing documents and by the lender rather than by statute. The arithmetic below applies to both kinds of community all the same.
Why an old number is a quiet problem
Construction costs in Florida have not stood still, and a limit that was accurate when the last appraisal was signed may now sit well below what it would cost to rebuild. Nothing on the renewal flags this. The carrier renews the limit it was given, the premium is calculated on it, and the gap stays invisible until a loss.
Many commercial property policies carry a coinsurance clause, usually 80, 90 or 100 percent. If the limit carried falls below that share of the true replacement cost, the claim is reduced in proportion, even when the loss is far smaller than the policy limit.
Worked as an illustration only:
Building limit on the policy, based on a 2023 appraisal: $12,000,000 Replacement cost today: $15,000,000 Coinsurance requirement: 90 percent, so $13,500,000 must be carried A covered loss of $900,000 is settled at 12,000,000 ÷ 13,500,000, or about 89 percent Recovery: roughly $800,000, less the deductible
The $100,000 difference, and the deductible, become a common expense under section 718.111(11)(j). Nobody at the carrier did anything wrong. The appraisal was simply three years old.
The appraisal moves the deductible too
A fresh appraisal rarely lowers the limit, and a higher limit changes a second number that boards tend to overlook.
Hurricane deductibles on Florida commercial residential policies are expressed as a percentage of the insured value. The Florida Department of Financial Services notes that insurers must offer percentage options that vary with the size of the limit, and that above $3 million only the 5 percent and 10 percent options are required. Raise the limit by $3,000,000 at a 5 percent deductible and the association's exposure in a named storm grows by $150,000 before the policy pays anything.
Section 718.111(11)(c) places that decision with the board. The deductible is set at a board meeting, must be consistent with industry standards for similar communities, and may be based on available funds, including reserves, or on predetermined assessment authority. Commercial residential policyholders are also given the choice between a calendar-year hurricane deductible and a separate deductible for each hurricane. That choice should be made deliberately rather than inherited from last year's form.
What the board should verify before signing
A short list is enough, and it can be worked through with the management company in one meeting.
- The date on the most recent appraisal, and whether it was a full appraisal or an update.
- Whether alterations and additions made since then are reflected in it. Under section 718.111(11)(f), the association's policy is required to cover alterations made under section 718.113(2).
- Whether the limit on the renewal quote matches the appraisal, or was carried forward from a prior year.
- Whether any inflation adjustment the carrier applied was tested against an actual valuation.
- Whether the flood limit was reconciled to the same replacement cost. The NFIP's 80 percent rule is explained in our guide to association flood insurance in Florida, and it runs on the same number.
The broader questions a board should put to its manager and agent at renewal are covered well in Condominium Associates' guide to insurance renewal questions, which pairs with this list.
Where Palm fits
Palm Insurance Management works with condominium and homeowners' associations across Tampa Bay from our office in Clearwater. A coverage review starts with two documents: the current declarations page and the most recent appraisal. From those, the gap between what is carried and what the building would cost to rebuild can be shown in plain numbers, along with what each deductible option would mean per unit.
Not sure where your association stands?
Send us your current declarations page and your most recent appraisal. We will tell you where the gaps are, whether or not you move your coverage to us.
1-866-612-1596 · 209 Turner Street, Clearwater, FL 33756
This article is general information, not legal advice or a statement of coverage. Coverage is governed solely by the terms of the policy issued. For advice about your association's specific situation, contact Palm Insurance Management at 1-866-612-1596.
Recent Posts








